MULTIPLICATIVE EVALUATION OF INFLUENCE OF THE ORGANIZATIONAL RISK FACTORS ON FLIGHT SAFETY IN AIR TRAFFIC CONTROL
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.18372/2306-1472.75.13114Keywords:
air traffic controller, coefficient of significance, expert questioning, flight safety, pairwise comparison method, ranking, risk factors, spider diagramAbstract
Purpose: to systematize the risk factors of organizational nature in Air Traffic Control system and to evaluate their complex influence on flight safety. Methods: the hazard degree of organizational factors in air traffic control has determined by the method of expert assessments, the scale of acceptability (admissibility) of the risk factors of organizational nature has constructed on the basis of the fuzzy sets theory with the use of linguistic variables. Results: it has revealed that air traffic control systems and equipment have the most significant influence on flight safety, company management and structure – the least one. The multiplicative function for evaluation of the flight safety in air traffic control has obtained, which allows checking the conformity of the values of organizational risk factors to the maximum permissible level of hazard. Discussion: proposed methodology for evaluation of the organizational risk factors influence on flight safety in air traffic control will allow developing the safety passports that can be applied by the State Aviation Administration of Ukraine during the certification inspections of air navigation service providers to compare the normative and actual indicators of their activities.
References
International Civil Aviation Organization (2013) Safety Management Manual (SMM). 3rd ed. Doc. ICAO 9859-AN 474. Canada, Montreal, ICAO Publ., 251 p.
Aviation Safety Network (2018) ASN data show 2017 was safest year in aviation history. Available at: https://news.aviation-safety.net/2017/12/30/preliminary-asn-data-show-2017-safest-year-aviation-history/ (accessed 03.03.2018)
State Aviation Administration of Ukraine (2017) Zvit shchodo vykonannya funktsiy nahlyadu za bezpekoyu pol'otiv u SOrPR v Ukrayini za 2016 rik [Report of the Implementation of Flight Safety Oversight Functions in the ATMS in Ukraine 2016]. Kyiv, State Aviation Administration of Ukraine Publ., 23 p. (In Ukrainian)
Kulik N., Kharchenko V., Lutskii M. (2008) Entsiklopediya bezopasnosti aviatsii [Encyclopedia of Aviation Safety]. Kyiv, Technology Publ., 1000 p. (In Russian)
International Civil Aviation Organization (2004) Cross-Cultural Factors in Aviation Safety: Human Factors Digest № 16. Сir. ІСАО 302-AN/175. Canada, Montreal, ICAO Publ., 39 p.
State Aviation Administration of Ukraine (2005) Polozhennya pro systemu upravlinnya bezpekoyu pol'otiv na aviatsiynomu transporti [Regulations on the Flight Safety Management System in Aviation Transport]. Approved by the order of SAAU from 11.25.2005 no. 895, 20 p. (In Ukrainian)
Ministry of Transport and Communications of Ukraine (2010) Polozhennya pro nahlyad za bezpekoyu pol'otiv u systemi orhanizatsiyi povitryanoho rukhu [Regulation on Flight Safety Oversight in Air Traffic Management System]. Approved by the order of MTCU from 05.31.2010 no. 320, 12 p. (In Ukrainian)
International Civil Aviation Organization (2005) Global Air Traffic Management Operational Concept. 1-st ed. Doc. ICAO 9854-AN 473. Canada, Montreal, ICAO Publ., 82 p.
Sikirda Yu., Shmelova T., Tkachenko D. (2017) Otsinyuvannya vplyvu orhanizatsiynykh faktoriv na bezpeku pol'otiv pry upravlinni povitryanym rukhom [Еvaluation of the Organizational Factors Influence on Flight Safety in Air Traffic Control]. Zbirnyk naukovykh prats' Kharkivs'koho natsional'noho universytetu Povitryanykh Syl, no. 3, рр. 39-44. (In Ukrainian)
Sikirda Yu., Tkachenko D. (2017) Еvaluation of the Organizational Factors Influence on Flight Safety in Air Traffic Control. Materialy ХІІІ mizhnar. nauk.-tekhn. konf. “AVIA-2017” [Proc. of ХІІІ Int. Scient.-Tech. conf.]. Kyiv, National Aviation University, pp. 11.64-11.66.
International Civil Aviation Organization (2008) Normal Operations Safety Survey (NOSS). 1-st ed. Doc. ICAO 9910-AN 473. Canada, Montreal, ICAO Publ., 85 p.
International Civil Aviation Organization (2008) Threat and Error Management (TEM) in Air Traffic Control. Cir. ICAO 314-AN/178. – Canada, Montreal, ICAO Publ., 34 p.
Velychko O. M., Kolomiyets' L. V., Hordiyenko T. B., Karpenko S. R., Haber A. A. (2015) Hrupove ekspertne otsinyuvannya ta kompetentnist' ekspertiv. Monohrafiya [Group expert assessment and experts’ competence. Monograph]. Odesa, Aprel Publ., 285 p. (In Ukrainian)
Kurtov A.I., Polikashyn O.V., Potikhens'kyy A.I., Aleksandrov V.M. (2017) Ekspertni otsinky. Metod “Delfi” yak tekhnolohiya pryynyattya upravlins’kykh rishen' [Expert Assessments. “Delphy” Method as Technology of Administrative Decision Making]. Zbirnyk naukovykh prats' Kharkivs'koho natsional'noho universytetu Povitryanykh Syl, no. 1 (50), pp. 118-122. (In Ukrainian)
Zimmermann H. J. (2006) Fuzzy Set Theory & Its Application. 4th ed. Softcove, Kluwer Academic Press Publ., 512 p.
