DIGITIZATION OF VAT – E-INVOICING AND CLEARANCE SYSTEM AS A MODEL

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.18372/2307-9061.73.19430

Keywords:

electronic invoice, fraud, electronic invoicing, B2B sales, process automation

Abstract

The purpose of the article is to study the features of the European experience in using electronic invoices, regarding the electronic administration of value added tax and the practical implementation of electronic invoices in Ukraine. From January 1, 2019, the European Union (Italy) introduced the requirement for electronic invoicing. Companies must create electronic invoices for B2G, B2B and B2C sales and send them to the invoice recipient in a defined XML format through a central platform. This allows the tax authorities to exercise control, which significantly reduced the VAT gap in the first few months after its introduction. Research methods: the study is based on general scientific methods as well as specific legal methods, with the help of which various scientific positions and doctrinal approaches to the development of ideas regarding understanding the concept and essence of legal fictions, as well as their significance in legal sphere, have been analyzed. Results: Ukraine still lags behind in using such digital opportunities. In order to combat fraud and reduce compliance costs for companies, the introduction of mandatory and largely standardized electronic invoicing with a central transmission platform should be considered. This is especially true for B2B sales. In addition, the complex standardized exchange of invoices creates huge opportunities for automating processes in the field of accounting. Discussion: the inclusion of B2C transactions should be analyzed in more detail. In any case, attention should be paid to (at least) nationwide implementation, which should be well prepared and early involvement of all involved actors. Ukraine must decide how it wants to respond to this development. Given the pioneering role of the EU. It turns out that the Italian registration procedure with mandatory electronic invoicing sets the course for digital VAT and can therefore be used as a blueprint for a possible Ukrainian system. The article describes the legal history of the origin of the Italian system and explains its functionality in more detail. It covers the creation of bound companies and shows how you can create, send and receive e-invoices. The Italian experience is examined for its transferability to Ukraine: what opportunities and risks exist for the administration and companies after implementation and what points are relevant after implementation.

Author Biography

Oleksandr Zaiets, Auszubildend Thien-Steuerberatung GmbH & Co. KG

Candidate of Law, Associate Professor, Intern

References

Center for Social and Economic Research und Institute for Advanced Studies, Study and Reports on the VAT Gap in the EU-28 Member States: 2019 Final Report, 2019. URL: ec.europa.eu/taxation_customs/sites/taxation/files/ vatgap-full-report-2019_en.pdf.

Center for Social and Economic Research und Institute for Advanced Studies; Study and Reports on the VAT Gap in the EU-28 Member States: 2019 Final Report, 2019, S. 19.

Ine Lejeune, Stein de Maeijer und Liesbeth Vermeire, Quick Reaction Mechanism against EU VAT Fraud, International VAT Monitor 2013, S. 94 (94-96).

Basiert auf Art. 205 MwStSystRL; bezüglich Polen siehe: [EN] Jan Sarnowski und Pawel Selera, Reducing the VAT Gap – Polish Experience and Legislative Measures Introduced in Years 2016-2018, International VAT Monitor 2019, S. 121 (122); zu Spanien: [EN] Ana Prósper-Almargo, Joint and Several Liability as a Measure to Tackle VATFraud: The Spanish Perspective, Intertax 2019, S. 304 (310-311).

Richtlinie 2014/55/EU des Europäischen Parlaments und des Rates vom 16. April 2014 über die elektronische Rechnungsstellung bei öffentlichen Aufträgen (ABl. L 133 vom 6.5.2014, S. 1–11).

Art. 233 und 246 MwStRSystRl; [ES] Real Decreto 1619/2012, de 30 de noviembre (BOE núm. 289, de 01.12.2012, p. 83180), Art. 8, 9.

[ES] Real Decreto 596/2016, de 2 de diciembre (BOE núm. 294, de 06.12. 2016, p. 85173); [ES] Real Decreto 1075/2017, de 29 de diciembre (BOE núm. 317, de 30 de diciembre de 2017, p. 130690), siehe auch: [ES/EN] www. agenciatribu-taria.es/AEAT.internet/en_gb/G417/informacion.shtml; für eine kurze Beschreibung siehe: [EN] Nicoletta Petrosino, Are You Ready for the Tax Technology?, International VAT Monitor 2019, S. 59 (60) mit Verweis auf [EN] Luis María Romero Flor, The New Spanish Immediate Information Supply System, International VAT Monitor 2018, S. 220.

[EN] EU Kommission und CEF Digital, eInvoicing in Hungary, 2020. URL: ec.europa.eu/cefdigital/wiki/display/ CEFDIGITAL/eInvoicing+in+Hungary.

[ES] Agencia Tributaria, Nuevo sistema de gestión del IVA basado en el Suministro Inmediato de Información. URL: www.agenciatributaria.es/ AEAT.internet/Inicio/Ayuda/Modelos__Procedimientos_y_Servicios/Ayuda_P_ G417____IVA__Llevanza_de_libros_registro__SII_/Informacion_general/Nuevo_sistema_de_gestion_del_IVA_basado_en_el_Suministro_Inmediato_de_ Informacion.shtml), zum data matching in Australien: [EN] Auditor General, The Australian Taxation Office’s Use of Data Matching and Analytics in Tax Administration, ANAO Audit Report No. 30 2007–08 (verfügbar unter www.anao.gov.au/work/performance-audit/australian-taxation-offices-use-data-matching-and-analytics-tax) oder dem Einsatz von risk assessment software u.A. in Österreich: Michael Huber, Sebastian Lacher und Berndt Zinnöcker, Digitalisierung in dedr Umsatzsteuer, ÖStZ 2019, S. 221.

[EN] Newton Oller de Mello et al, The Implementation of the Electronic Tax Documents in Brazil as a Tool to Fight Tax Evasion, in Recent Advances in Systems, Nikos Mastorakis et al (Hrsg.) 1. Auflage 2009, S. 449 (452-453).

[FR] République Française, Projet de Loi des Finances pour 2020, 27.09.2019 (verfügbar unter. URL: http://www.assemblee-nationale.fr/dyn/ 15/textes/l15b2272_projet-loi.pdf), Art. 56.

Published

2024-12-30

How to Cite

Zaiets, O. (2024). DIGITIZATION OF VAT – E-INVOICING AND CLEARANCE SYSTEM AS A MODEL. Scientific Works of National Aviation University. Series: Law Journal "Air and Space Law", 4(73), 103–108. https://doi.org/10.18372/2307-9061.73.19430

Issue

Section

CONSTITUTIONAL AND ADMINISTRATIVE LAW